The first settlement in Afton was made in July, 1786, many more settlers soon followed. More Early Settlers
- Atherton, Cornelius
- Betts, Peter Judge
- Buck, Daniel S.
- Church, Richard
- Easton, Oliver
- Hyde, Daniel
- Johnston, John
- Johnston, William
- Pearsall, Henry
- Pollard, David
- Stevens, Abijah
- Stone, Seth
- Stowel, Hezekiah